
Why?
It is one of the most difficult questions I have encountered in my career as a funeral director.
I have heard it asked by grieving families countless times. I have sat with people in some of their deepest moments of pain and confusion as they searched for an answer that neither of us could find. It has sparked conversations between us that always end with many tears, and neither of us finding the answer.
Why?
Why has proven time after time to be one of life’s most difficult questions. It is almost like a riddle with no real answer.
Why do bad things happen? Why does tragedy exist? Why them? Why me?
The human brain wants an explanation. In the middle of tragedy and confusion, we search for something that makes sense—something we can hold onto. There has to be some reason why. Some reasonable explanation that speaks to logic and gives this pain a reason to exist.
Human life is so intricate and complex. Things don’t just happen for no reason. People don’t cross paths by mistake, and life is too precious to have it all be for nothing.
But then there are circumstances that force you to confront just how difficult—and sometimes impossible—it is to come up with an answer.
Why does a 7-year-old child become terminally ill with a rare and aggressive form of cancer?
Why does a young man with a family who loves him very much die from the cruel hands of addiction, never recovering and making it out?
Why do accidents happen to innocent people who are simply stopped at a red light, waiting to turn into work?
Why do loving spouses and parents get brain tumors, suffering in front of their families through a long, drawn-out illness?
Why do sweet, innocent babies die of SIDS?
And why do people choose to end their own lives and leave countless loved ones behind to forever suffer in their absence?
You can try different scenarios. You can try every possible outcome. You can sit for hours on end posing the why in these cases.
You can think you’ve found an answer, or at least a semi-answer. But saying it out loud can make that answer seem just as illogical as the question itself.
Wrong.
Insignificant.
Senseless.
One of the most cherished experiences of my career—and one I will never forget—was a conversation I had with a grieving mother.
This heartbroken and grief-stricken mother turned to me with tears streaming down her face and asked me why.
My eyes began to well with tears as I watched her look up toward the sky in pain and confusion, almost as if she were seeking an answer from God himself in real time.
The raw emotion between us in that room was so heavy.
She asked me for guidance. She asked me how I do this every day.
The tears began to fall freely down my face as my voice cracked.
“I want you to know that these are the days that I leave my office asking God why. I don’t understand, and I never will understand. I truly don’t believe that there is an answer to that question, and I struggle with that question daily. There is no reason why that is good enough to make this make sense.”
And that, I have come to realize, may be the real answer to the why.
There is no answer.
No answer is good enough. No answer that will suffice. No explanation that could possibly make these losses or these circumstances feel fair.
A well-known grief quote comes to mind when thinking about the why:
“I think I will ask God why for the rest of my life, and never will I come to understand it. Even if God himself came in front of me and told me the reason, I don’t think I would accept it. Some loves are too hard to bear, and with great love comes great pain. And with great loss comes the greatest pain of all. If love could have saved you, you would have lived forever.” —Unknown
That quote helped me realize something I had been struggling to accept.
I was chasing an answer that may not exist.
Many nights, I came home from work and sat in silence thinking about the why behind the cases I had seen. Other days, I would walk through the grocery store completely zoned out and lost in my own thoughts, looking for an answer while going through the motions of everyday life.
I carried these questions everywhere.
And eventually, they began to take their toll.
I felt depressed. I felt hopeless. I didn’t just carry the question with me for one person. I carried it with me, unanswered, for many.
Then someone close to me challenged me to change the question.
Instead of asking why, ask what.
At first, it puzzled me. But the more I thought about it, the more I realized how different the two questions were and what that change meant.
“Why?” left me searching for an explanation I might never find.
“What?” gave me somewhere to go.
What did this person teach me?
What will I carry with me from knowing their story?
What can I learn from their life?
What can I do to honor them?
What can I carry forward?
What can I give to someone else because of what they gave to me?
The “what” was much more giving with its answers.
It didn’t leave me in an endless and hopeless rabbit hole. It gave me something tangible—something I could carry with me as I continued moving forward.
It became a way for me to process the things I had seen without feeling like I was staying stagnant in an endless and depressing cycle.
And I began to find answers.
One of my first answers to “what” came on the day of the funeral for the person I mentioned earlier.
Everyone seemed to have essentially the same thing to say about this person.
What a light they were. How welcome they made the people around them feel. How much they loved life. How they enjoyed every moment and spread joy to others everywhere they went.
It was evident to me what a light this person truly was, even though I had never met them.
They had left behind a wonderful legacy.
A light so bright that even death couldn’t dim it.
That light remained in every fond memory and every conversation. It had been passed on to everyone they came into contact with—people who would never forget how that person made them feel.
And those people could now carry that light with them, too.
They could become that same light for someone else.
That day, standing there in my suit, the lightbulb came on for me.
I could find a “what” from every single person I cared for.
Sometimes, I could find multiple whats.
And then I could spread those whats to other people.
Ever since that day, I think of that wonderful person’s life whenever an opportunity presents itself for me to be a light.
I carry that lesson with me as something I learned from that case—something I can keep with me and pass on to someone else.
In doing so, I keep their memory and the impact they had on me alive.
In my first post, “We Are Not Immune To Death,” I discussed a young woman who deeply touched me at the beginning of my career.
I have taken so much from her story, and it has brought me to where I am today.
The “what” I took from her was that it is okay to have emotions for people you care for in the death care industry, even when you have never met them before.
It is okay to show those emotions.
It is okay to allow those emotions to help you connect with special families.
It is okay to talk about them openly.
Without that “what,” I would not have half of the stories and connections I have formed today.
Without that “what,” I don’t believe I would have even pursued this platform.
And maybe that is the difference.
I now understand that I may never have the answers to those whys.
If the answers do exist, I truly do not believe they are good enough to make these tragedies make sense.
But I don’t have to understand the why to find something meaningful in the what.
I can find a million whats in the lives of the people I have been fortunate enough to care for.
A lesson.
A memory.
A reminder.
A piece of their story.
Something they taught me without ever knowing they were teaching me.
Something I can carry forward.
Something I can pass on to the next person.
That feeling gives me purpose.
It gives me something I can carry with me every day without allowing the unanswered questions to feel quite so heavy.
I may never understand why some people are taken too soon.
I may never understand why some families have to endure unimaginable pain.
I may never understand why some stories end the way they do.
But I have learned that I don’t need an answer to every why in order to find something worth carrying forward.
The why may always be there.
But so can the what.
And the “what” keeps my heart on its toes—always looking for something to carry with me, and hopefully, pass on to the next person.
Maybe I will never understand the “why.”
Maybe I don’t have to.
Maybe the most meaningful thing I can do is take the good that I can from the people I meet, carry their light with me, and make sure it doesn’t end with them.
And maybe that is enough.




